Currently, discarded products are often considered as ‘waste’, while in the best cases, some parts are recovered or the product is recycled to recover materials. A circular economy model closes the production cycle to optimise the use of resources and minimise the generation of waste. In this model there is a recovery hierarchy; first, the complete product is recovered, then its parts and the materials, and, finally, the embedded energy is recovered. Landfill disposal is the last option since it does not recover any resources.
Full product recovery is thus the most sustainable strategy in this hierarchy. Product recovery is a process that seeks to increase the value of discarded objects through a revalorisation process, in order to reintroduce them into the economic-productive system.
There are four valorisation processes for full product recovery, which differ from each other due to the modifications they make on the product:
Reuse: using a discarded product again without making any changes, or with some small changes. The owner may remain the same (1st hand), in which case the changes depend on the user, but there may be a change in the product ownership (2nd hand), in which case there will be a repair and evaluation phase before returning the product to a secondary market.
Renovate: the process of returning a product to an aesthetic state that makes it look 'like new' through various treatments like cleaning, polishing, painting, etc. It includes repairing damaged components. These products are generally destined for secondary markets.
Reconditioning: the process of returning a product to its original technical condition or a ‘like new’ condition by repairing damaged components and replacing or repairing components that will soon become obsolete (preventive repair). The output quality of the final product may be lower than the original, therefore the warranty is typically lower. These products are usually destined for secondary markets.
Remanufacturing: the process of returning a product or component to an equivalent or superior state to that of the original product. It can include an update phase to improve the performance of the product with respect to the original, therefore the warranty of the remanufactured product or component can be like a new product.
To choose the best revalorisation process for a discarded product, it is important to establish the profitability of the process by comparing how it will increase the product value and the costs related to that process. In general, remanufacturing is the process which increases the product value the most, followed by reconditioning, then renovate, and last by reuse.
On the other hand, comparing the costs related to each revalorisation process, reuse is the cheapest one, followed by renovating, then reconditioning, and last by remanufacturing. Nevertheless, all four revalorisation processes are usually cheaper than manufacturing a new product and achieve considerable savings because of lower resource consumption.
European Remanufacturing Network (ERN). Map of Remanufacturing Processes Landscape (D3.3 – D3.4), June 2016, A report for the European Commission under Horizon 2020,
http://www.remanufacturing.eu/assets/pdfs/ERN_DeliverableReport_WP3_Proc...
Ihobe, Environmental Management Agency (2016), Ideas notebook #13: Ecodesign for a Circular Economy. Basque Ecodesign Center,
http://www.basqueecodesigncenter.net/Paginas/Ficha.aspx?IdMenu=f56ec9fa-...
Ihobe, Environmental Management Agency (2017). Ideas notebook #15: Ecodesign for
product recovery, Basque Ecodesign Center,
http://www.basqueecodesigncenter.net/Paginas/Ficha.aspx?IdMenu=4dd23f12-...
Reman, re[value]manufacturing, http://www.remanufacturing.fr/en/
CEN/CLC/JTC 10 - Energy-related products - Material Efficiency Aspects for Ecodesign.
Under development, due to be completed in 2019
European Remanufacturing Network (ERN), Map of Remanufacturing Business Model
Landscape, May 2016, A report for the European Commission under Horizon 2020,
http://remanufacturing.eu/assets/pdfs/ERN-D-3-1-Map-of-Remanufacturing-B...
European Remanufacturing Network (ERN), Remanufacturing Market Study, November
2015, A report for the European Commission under Horizon 2020,
http://www.remanufacturing.eu/assets/pdfs/remanufacturing-market-study.pdf
Ihobe, Environmental Management Agency (2018). The Circular Economy in Basque
Country: Analysis
ISO 14009 - Guidelines for incorporating redesign of products and components to
improve material circulation, due to be completed in 2020